Does Silence Mean Approval? USDT Exec Critiques EU’s MiCA Stance

Coinbase, a leading U.S.-based cryptocurrency exchange, preemptively delisted USDT from its European services earlier in December 2024, citing MiCA compliance concerns. Other major platforms like Binance and Crypto.com, however, have opted to continue offering USDT in Europe.

Despite MiCA’s imminent enforcement, European regulators have not explicitly stated whether USDT meets the new compliance standards. This regulatory silence has left market participants divided. Juan Ignacio Ibañez, a member of the MiCA Crypto Alliance’s Technical Committee, explained, “No regulators have explicitly stated that USDT is non-compliant, but that does not mean it is compliant.”

Source: X

This move by Coinbase to delist USDT shows the conservative approach the firm takes toward avoidance of any compliance risk at the last minute. In contrast, other exchanges, including Binance and Crypto.com, remain open for USDT trading as they await further clarity.

Industry experts warn that USDT’s non-compliance could lead to significant disruptions. Jacob Kinge, a financial analyst, pointed out that Tether has halted new coin issuance in recent weeks, raising concerns about liquidity and transaction costs. “A formal ban on USDT would likely increase costs for traders and disrupt market liquidity,” Kinge remarked.

Moreover, Joseph Hurtado, founder of Granata Consulting, noted broader implications: “Restricting USDT could weaken Europe’s position as a hub for cryptocurrency innovation.”

MiCA includes a transitional phase allowing entities operating under national laws to adapt to the new framework. The “grandfathering” clause permits existing service providers to continue operations until July 1, 2026, or until they obtain or are denied MiCA authorization. However, the length of this transitional period varies by country, ranging from six months in the Netherlands to 18 months in France.

MiCA Implementation Timeline. Source: ESMA

While this flexibility provides breathing room for market participants, it also creates uneven levels of consumer protection across the EU. “Waiting without acting could prove risky in the long term,” warned Ibañez, emphasizing the importance of proactive measures.

Tether’s operations have faced scrutiny over its auditing practices. Critics like Jason Calacanis, host of the All-In Podcast, questioned Tether’s reliance on assurance reports from BDO Italia rather than audits by major firms. Meanwhile, Tether CEO Paolo Ardoino defended the company’s practices, highlighting efforts to expand USDT’s practical use cases and network collaborations.

As the December 30 deadline approaches, the future of USDT in Europe remains uncertain. While some platforms adopt a wait-and-see approach, others, like Coinbase, are prioritizing compliance. The regulatory ambiguity underscores the challenges of balancing technological innovation with strict oversight.

Source: X

The European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) has yet to provide definitive guidance on USDT’s status under MiCA. As exchanges and market participants navigate this transitional phase, the need for clear, cohesive directives from regulators is more pressing than ever.

The MiCA regulation represents a critical milestone for the European cryptocurrency market, aiming to enhance transparency and consumer protection. However, the lack of clarity regarding key assets like USDT highlights the complexities of implementing such sweeping reforms. As the industry adapts to these changes, the stakes are high for both market participants and regulators to find a path that ensures stability without stifling innovation.