Judge Acquits ‘MEV Brothers’ in $25 Million Ethereum Case, Finding No Misrepresentation
Anton and James Peraire-Bueno, the brothers charged over a $25 million exploit of Ethereum trading bots in 2023, have been acquitted of all remaining charges, and the court has closed their case. U.S. District Judge Jess...
Watchlist
Fresh in the current trading session. The story has cross-source confirmation.
Anton and James Peraire-Bueno, the brothers charged over a $25 million exploit of Ethereum trading bots in 2023, have been acquitted of all remaining charges, and the court has closed their case.
U.S. District Judge Jessica G. L. Clarke granted their motion for a judgment of acquittal on Monday, Nov. 16, writing that the government never pointed to a material misrepresentation in how the brothers executed their trades. Wire fraud requires one, she wrote. Because the money laundering conspiracy count rested on a wire fraud finding, it fell too, along with the wire fraud conspiracy charge.
“The question before the court is not whether the Peraire-Buenos’ conduct was right or moral, or even whether it violated uncharged crimes,” Clarke wrote in the opinion.
Get Unchained’s crypto news in your inbox with the free Unchained Daily newsletter.
A Year After the MistrialThe ruling comes a year after the brothers’ nearly four-week trial ended in a mistrial when jurors deadlocked after three days of deliberations. Prosecutors indicted them in May 2024.
The case centered on maximal extractable value (MEV), the profit available from how transactions are ordered inside a block, and on MEV-Boost, open-source software from Flashbots that validators, the computers that propose and confirm new blocks, run to earn more from those blocks.
Prosecutors said the brothers placed bait transactions to lure sandwich traders, bots that place trades on either side of another user’s order. The bots responded with bundles, groups of trades sent privately to be executed together in a set order. The brothers used a bug in the relay code that passes blocks to validators to see those bundles, which the traders believed were private, then swapped the bait for their own transactions, and the bots lost about $25 million in roughly 12 seconds. Flashbots patched the relay code within 24 hours.
Clarke rejected the government’s comparison to spoofing, where traders place orders they intend to cancel. The brothers’ bait transactions were published to the blockchain within about a minute, she noted, and Ethereum is not a regulated market with rules barring the conduct. Evidence that the pair hid their identities afterward went to intent, she wrote, and could not replace a false statement.
Daniel Marx of Fick & Marx, who represents Anton, said in a statement that the ruling showed the brothers “never lied to anyone about their trading activity,” according to Reuters. Katherine Trefz of Williams & Connolly, James’s lawyer, called it “the just and correct outcome,” Reuters reported.
What the Ruling SignalsClarke cited a 2025 decision in the same court that acquitted a trader of wire fraud after he withdrew more than $100 million from Mango Markets, also for lack of a false statement. Read together, the two rulings suggest that prosecutors who bring wire fraud charges over a code exploit on a platform with no terms of use will have to identify a specific misrepresentation, and that a victim’s expectations or a defendant’s efforts to hide do not stand in for one.
Related Listen: Why MEV Will Always Be Controversial
{"@context":"https:\/\/schema.org","@id":"https:\/\/unchainedcrypto.com\/judge-acquits-mev-brothers-in-25-million-ethereum-case-finding-no-misrepresentation\/#arve-youtube-2rwu2ah4crg","@type":"VideoObject","embedUrl":"https:\/\/www.youtube-nocookie.com\/embed\/2rwu2ah4Crg?feature=oembed&iv_load_policy=3&modestbranding=1&rel=0&autohide=1&playsinline=1&autoplay=0","name":"Why MEV Will Always Be Controversial","description":"Two of Ethereum’s leading thinkers dive deep into the current state of maximal extractable value.","thumbnailUrl":"https:\/\/unchainedcrypto.com\/wp-content\/uploads\/2023\/04\/UN482-SOCIAL.jpg","uploadDate":"2023-04-18T11:00:30+00:00"}
The post Judge Acquits ‘MEV Brothers’ in $25 Million Ethereum Case, Finding No Misrepresentation appeared first on Unchained.
Why this matters
Ethereum is showing up inside the Security Incidents theme, so this story is worth tracking for follow-through rather than treating it as a one-off headline.
Original source
Read on UnchainedSame story, other sources
Cross-source coverage
2 sources
Judge Acquits Brothers in $25 Million Ethereum MEV Case After Finding No Proven Wire Fraud
TL;DR A federal judge acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno in the $25 million Ethereum MEV c...
Related market context
Lighter Reopens Withdrawals, Hands 5 Million USDC Back to Drained Trader
About 5 million USDC is back with a trader whose Lighter accounts were drained Monday morning, and the perpetual futures exchange...
Ethereum Price and $1.16B Selling Threat: North Korea’s Binance Hacker Moves $137M
Ethereum price is facing another challenge as a North Korea-linked hacker moves $137 million in ETH. The massive transfer comes as...
Former Robinhood engineer pleads guilty to wire fraud over trades ahead of crypto listing announcements
A former Robinhood engineer faces up to 20 years after admitting to profiting from Hyperliquid trades ahead of crypto listing anno...
CoinGecko CEO says 39% of its 15 million tracked tokens live on Solana
Solana's majority stake in CoinGecko could significantly influence token tracking and trading features, potentially reshaping cryp...
Bitwise expands beyond crypto with new AI cybersecurity ETF holding Palo Alto and Cloudflare
Bitwise's ZDAY ETF highlights the growing importance of AI cybersecurity, signaling a shift in investment focus towards emerging t...
Chainlink Confidential Compute logs 1 million workflow runs using AWS enclaves
Chainlink's Confidential Compute could revolutionize blockchain privacy, enabling secure onchain operations and boosting instituti...