No, Someone Didn’t Really Pay $532 Million for a CryptoPunk NFT
CryptoPunks are the ultimate blue chip of NFT avatar collections, with dozens of seven-figure USD sales and more than $1.5 billion of trading volume to date. Even so, a half-billion dollar sale is sure to turn a lot of h...
Archive context
Older archive item. Useful for background and entity history, but not a fresh market-moving signal.
CryptoPunks are the ultimate blue chip of NFT avatar collections, with dozens of seven-figure USD sales and more than $1.5 billion of trading volume to date. Even so, a half-billion dollar sale is sure to turn a lot of heads, as it did earlier this evening.
But while a transaction was made, it wasn’t a legitimate sale. CryptoPunk #9998 triggered a sale alert just before 8pm EST on Wednesday, with a transaction price of more than 124,457 ETH, or $532 million at the time of sale.
Given that the all-time CryptoPunk sale record was merely $11.8 million, and that the current single NFT record is just over $69 million for digital artwork from Beeple, red flags immediately popped up. Some suspected a brazen act of wash trading, potentially to hide ill-gotten crypto gains, albeit one that would be very visible on a public blockchain like Ethereum.
Punk 9998 bought for 124,457.07 ETH ($532,414,877.01 USD) by 0x9b5a5c from 0x8e3983. https://t.co/dmT6jDRC1W #cryptopunks #ethereum pic.twitter.com/UQlmm1oqkj
— CryptoPunks Bot (@cryptopunksbot) October 28, 2021
Upon closer inspection, however, the transaction looks to be the work of someone playing around with DeFi flash loans, or uncollateralized crypto loans. In other words, it wasn’t an exploit.
“In a nutshell, someone bought this punk from themself with borrowed money and repaid the loan in the same transaction,” CryptoPunks creator Larva Labs tweeted. “Some recent large bids were done the same way. The ether is offered and removed in a single transaction. So, while technically briefly valid, the bid can never be accepted.”
Larva Labs’ trading platform still lists the transaction for the sale, but also shows that the buyer’s wallet ultimately ended up transferring the NFT back to the seller’s wallet.
Robert Miller, a steward at research organization Flashbots, tweeted a more detailed description of events. As he writes, the first contract put the CryptoPunk up for sale, and then a second contract borrowed an enormous amount of money via a flash loan and bought it. At that point, the first contract sent the money back to the second one, and then the loan was repaid.
Why, exactly? It appears that someone was shifting a bunch of cryptocurrency around for the hell of it—and a comparatively tiny transaction fee of about $800.
In fact, a closer look at Etherscan reveals a note in the transaction’s input data box when you view it with the UTF-8 display option. It reads: “‘looks rare’ - blurr n' arr00.”
Why a CryptoPunks Owner Turned Down $9.5M in Ethereum for His NFTLarva Labs tweeted that it will add filters to transaction notifications so that such flash loan-fueled, non-valid transactions will no longer be shared out to the world. And CryptoSlam, a popular NFT analytics platform, said that it will delete the sale from its data set.
In other words, it’s almost like the $532 million CryptoPunk sale never happened. But it sure got people talking, didn’t it?
Why this matters
This nft story adds another data point to the current market tape and is useful when read alongside nearby source coverage.
Original source
Read on DecryptRelated market context
Judge Acquits ‘MEV Brothers’ in $25 Million Ethereum Case, Finding No Misrepresentation
Anton and James Peraire-Bueno, the brothers charged over a $25 million exploit of Ethereum trading bots in 2023, have been acquitt...
Judge Acquits Brothers in $25 Million Ethereum MEV Case After Finding No Proven Wire Fraud
TL;DR A federal judge acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno in the $25 million Ethereum MEV case. The court found prosecutors ha...
Ethereum Price and $1.16B Selling Threat: North Korea’s Binance Hacker Moves $137M
Ethereum price is facing another challenge as a North Korea-linked hacker moves $137 million in ETH. The massive transfer comes as...
Bitcoin’s $60,000 Put Takes the Lead With $900 Million in Open Positions
Bitcoin options traders have a new focal point: the $60,000 put strike, where approximately $900 million in outstanding notional p...
CoinGecko Gets Solana Foundation Backing and Plans Solana-Powered Trading
CoinGecko, one of the most widely used crypto price and market data sites, has a new backer in the Solana Foundation, the nonprofi...
Ethereum test exposes flaw that lets transactions skip payments
Developer-published Juicebox V6 simulations report four missed-payment paths under tested Glamsterdam rules, adding concrete cases...